Mafia Romance

The nexus of innocence, danger, and high-stakes steam. Only she can make his cold, dark heart beat.

Looking for Motorcycle Romance? IT'S OVER HERE. 
We see you’re into something a bit more ‘morally grey’. Don't miss our Dark Romance recs or find something more Heartbreaking.
Searching for a title that’s not listed? Check our lower-rated reads page for books we don’t recommend and why.

Mafia Romance

🔥🔥🔥

Read-&-Rated Favorites (⭐ 3.5+)

  • Book cover for 'Be With Me' by Gabrielle Sands, featuring a man with dark hair and stubble, wearing a black shirt, posing with his hand on his head against a dark background.

    Be With Me by Gabrielle Sands

    4.5

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “So good. The friction between Mia and Romolo is coming from all angles. That ending was not one I saw coming.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Enemies to Lovers, MMC/FMC has a Medical Condition, Forbidden Love Interest

  • Book cover for 'Queen of Hearts' by Sarah Blue, featuring a woman with blonde hair in a red lace dress, sitting against a black background with a heart symbol and 'High Roller Omegas' label.

    Queen of Hearts by Sarah Blue

    ⭐ 4.5

    HOT, HEA

    “This was so good. It was an Omegaverse Mafia book that scratched every itch. It was intriguing, dark, adventurous, emotional, and funny.” - Cardigan B

    Omegaverse, MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Kidnapping, Revenge, Arranged Marriage, Friends to Lovers, Workplace, Grumpy/Sunshine

  • Book cover of "Beautiful Beast" by Neva Altaj. Features a tattooed, suited man's hands with rings, holding a bloody rose, against a background of dark roses. Text includes "An Age Gap Forced Proximity Mafia Romance" and "Mafia Legacy - Perfectly Imperfect."

    Beautiful Beast by Neva Altaj

    4.25

    HOT, HEA

    “I loved everything about this book. Loved, loved, loved.” - Penelope Black

    “Heart emojis everywhere. They angry-banged a lot.” - Cardigan B

    25+ FMC, Arranged Marriage, Mafia, Tortured MMC, Touch Her and Die Vibes, Forced Proximity, Enemies to Lovers, Grumpy/Sunshine, Age Gap, Kidnapping, Russian FMC, Italian MMC, Secret Identity, Forbidden Love Interest, Witty Banter, Slow Burn

  • Book cover of 'Broken Whispers' by Neva Altaj, featuring a mysterious man with rings, dark tones, and elegant typography.

    Broken Whispers by Neva Altaj

    4.25

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I loved the physical language barrier that existed (even if it was pretend) so they got into a rhythm of paying attention to each other and finding a new way to exist.”- Cardigan B

    Ballerina, Age Gap, Sign Language, Scarred MMC, Touch her and die, Mafia, Russian MMC, Bratva, Beauty & The Beast, Arranged Marriage, Doesn't Speak

  • Book cover for 'Where Dark Hearts Devour' by Victoria Holliday featuring dark teal background, ornate frame, purple and blue flowers, and jewelry embellishments.

    Where Dark Hearts Devour (Book 1) by Victoria Holiday

    4.25

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “The tension between Castiano and Trilby is tangible. Really well done. The first honest virgin "first time" I've heard described. "It felt like razor blades." Yeah, it hurts. Never seen a tail bone called a ‘sit bone’ before.” - Cardigan B

    Age 20+ FMC, Age Gap Romance, Italian FMC, Italian MMC, MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Loss of Parent (Death), Arranged Marriage, Slow Burn, Forced Proximity, Bodyguard

  • Book cover titled 'Where Wild Hearts Dance' by Victoria Holliday, with a purple and black background, decorated with flowers, of which some are pink, and purple boots.

    Where Wild Hearts Dance (Book 2) by Victoria Holliday

    4.0

    HOT, HEA

    “Ooo Victoria got creative with this one. Benny is hard not to love. He burned down his own house for her! That scene on the car at the beach was sooooomething.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Age Gap Romance, Tattoos, Loss of Parent (Death), Possessive MMC, Overcoming Past Trauma, Older Woman/Younger Man, Kidnapping

  • Book cover titled "Where Quiet Hearts Scream" by Victoria Holliday, featuring a dark background with purple and gray flowers, a decorative red frame, and gold and beige text.

    Where Quiet Hearts Scream (Book 3) by Victoria Holliday

    ⭐ 4.0

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “This book was heartbreaking from beginning to end. You could feel Sera's desperation to build her own life and to have it RIPPED from her hands, watching Andreas set fire to it. Oh god, my heart. Well done. Self-harm (cutting) was anguish for me.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia, Mistaken Identity, Arranged Marriage, Healing Together, Past Coming Back to Haunt Them, Loss of Parent (Death), Captive Falls for Captor, Forgiveness Arc, Politics, Redemption, Virgin FMC

  • Book cover for 'Where Reckless Hearts Whisper' by Victoria Holliday, featuring a dark, vintage background with flowers and a camera, and gold ornate frame design.

    Where Reckless Hearts Whisper (Book 4) by Victoria Holliday

    ⭐ 3.5

    HOT, HEA

    “"He reaches a hand between us and paws at my clit" WHAT?! I got the sense in this series finale that the author was ready to be done with it. This was the perfect example - to date, her descriptions have been so elegant and sensual. And the constant reminders that they’re step siblings. It’s taboo, we get it.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia, Step-Sibling Crush, Arranged Marriage, Forbidden Love Interest, Kidnapping, Rescue, Age Gap Romance, Loss of Parent (Death), Loss of Sibling (Death), Grumpy/Sunshine, Virgin FMC, Gang Wars

  • Close-up of a hand with tattoos holding another person's hand, both in dark clothing. The background is dark with gold rose patterns at the bottom. The title reads 'Fractured Souls' and the subtitle 'A Perfectly Imperfect Series,' written by Neva Altaj. Additional text includes 'An Age Gap Mafia Romance.'

    Fractured Souls by Neva Altaj

    ⭐ 4.0

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I loved this one. I think this was my first Neva book. She can’t stand up for herself so so e protects her. Sweet, sad, hopeful.” - Cardigan B

    Healing Together, MMC Nurses FMC Back to Life, Overcoming Past Trauma, Possessive MMC, Age Gap Romance, Mafia/Organized Crime, Bratva, Protective MMC, Slow Burn Due to Past Trauma, Forced Proximity, MMC/FMC is/are on the Run

  • Book cover for "Hunted by a Shadow," part of the "Kings of Mafia" series by Michelle Heard, featuring a man in a suit and tie.

    Hunted By a Shadow by Michelle Heard

    4.0

    HOT, HEA

    “Ooooo this was dark. It was uncomfortable. It was just what I wanted. Skylar needs a kidney. Her dad stops at nothing to get one. He accidentally commissions one from organ farmers and they kill Renzo's next in line to get it.” - Cardigan B

    Mafia/Organized Crime, Organ Trafficking, Kidnapping, Loss of Sibling, Touch her and die, Age Gap, Morally Grey MMC, Chef

  • Book cover of 'Kingdom Fall' by A. Zavarelli, featuring a well-dressed man in a suit against a cityscape background. The text includes 'USA Today Bestselling Author' and 'IVI Imperium Valens Invictum' emblem.

    Kingdom Fall by A. Zavarelli

    4.0

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I like this one. Just could have saved each other a lot of trouble with some simple communication. But hey, what do I know. I'm just the reader.” - Penelope Black

    Boss/Nanny, Nanny, Enemies to Lovers, MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, MC is a Single Parent, Virgin MMC, Age Gap Romance, Revenge, Forced Proximity, Secret Pregnancy, Doesn't Speak, Arranged Marriage, Slow Burn, Rape

  • The cover of "The Monster" by L.J. Shen featuring a black and white photo of a man looking to the side, with Boston Belles series logo in the corner.

    The Monster by L.J. Shen

    4.0

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “They could have been doing way more dark corner banging this whole time, as I was led to believe from the book jacket.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Grumpy/Sunshine, Age Gap Romance, Brother's Best Friend, Touch Her and Die Vibes, Secret Relationship, Unrequited Love

  • Book cover titled "Nero: Alliance Book One" by S.J. Tilly featuring a man in a suit seated, with his hand on his chin and partially obscured face.

    Nero by S.J. Tilly

    4.0

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I liked this one the best out of the series. It was a little wild given he just walked into her apartment to hide from the cops.” - Penelope Black

    “Really liked this. FUCK HANS. There, I said it.” - Cardigan B

    Mafia/Organized Crime, Shy FMC, Overcoming Past Trauma, Morally Grey (MMC), Childhood Trauma, Curvier FMC, Tall MMC

  • Cover of a book titled 'Precious Hazard' by Neva Altaj, featuring a close-up of two hands with wedding rings, against a dark floral background.

    Precious Hazard by Neva Altaj

    4.0

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “Tara knows the definition of ‘malicious compliance’ and uses it with gusto. Her spirit is infectious.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Arranged Marriage, FMC & MMC Enter Into A Contract, Enemies to Lovers, Best Friend's Older Brother, Overcoming Past Trauma, Slow Burn

  • The Predator by RuNyx book cover. Dark Verse book one.

    The Predator by RuNyx

    4.0

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I still don't understand what the hell the codes have to do with anything, but I absolutely LOVE Tristan - years of being a super tough villain has hardened him, but it's fun to watch him become a human with feelings.” - Penelope Black

    AntiMMC, Enemies to LoversForced Proximity, Revenge, MMC rides a motorcycle, Touch her and die, Slow Burn

  • Book Cover for "Silent Lies" by Neva Altaj. Close-up of a man wearing a dark suit with a textured pattern, touching his neck with his hand. He is wearing a wristwatch with a brown leather strap.

    Silent Lies by Neva Altaj

    ⭐ 4.0

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “If ever an FMC needed to be seen, it's Sienna. Drago was absolutely the right man for her. He loved her for her heart, chicken sweater and all.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Age 20+ FMC, Age 35+ MMC, Age Gap Romance, Italian FMC, Grumpy/Sunshine, Virgin FMC, Loss of Parent (Death), Loss of Sibling (Death)

  • Cover of a book titled "Sinners Anonymous" by Somme SketCher. It features a vintage black rotary phone on a dark wooden surface, with a torn piece of paper reading "Sinners Anonymous Book One." The title "Sinners" is in bold white letters, and "anonymous" is written in red cursive.

    Sinners Anonymous (Book 1) by Somme Sketcher

    4.0

    HOT, HEA

    “A mafia arranged marriage. A forbidden love. A strange focus on birds. This book had everything. I LOVED Angelo. Normally for this type of spice, I'd call this MEDIUM, but the spanking in church put it to HOT.” - Cardigan B

    Age Gap, Father’s Fiancee, Power Struggle, Family Rivalry, To-Be Continued, Secrets, Touch Her & Die, Hate to Love You

  • Playing cards and poker chips with the title 'Sinners Condemned' and the author's name, Sonme Sketcher

    Sinners Condemned (Book 2) by Somme Sketcher

    ⭐ 4.0

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I did like this one and the games they played were fun. The yacht thing was weird. And it never really seemed like he liked her.” - Cardigan B

    Age Gap Romance, MC is involved in Mafia, Hidden Identity, To-Be Continued, Touch Her and Die Vibes, Morally Grey MMC, Possessive MMC, Obsessive MMC, Enemies to Lovers, Hate to Love You, Opposites Attract, Spanking, Dirty Talker, Rich/Wealthy MMC, Gang Wars

  • Book cover of 'The Sweetest Oblivion' by Danielle Lori, featuring a hand holding a playing card with a heart symbol; part of the Made Series.

    The Sweetest Oblivion (Book 1) by Danielle Lori

    4.0

    HOT, HEA

    “Dear god, the angst with these two. Pretty hilarious though with the sister getting knocked up by the pool boy, gardener?” - Penelope Black

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Arranged Marriage, Morally Grey MMC, Dirty Talker, Enemies to Lovers, Marriage of Convenience, Age Gap Romance, Slow Burn, Forced Proximity, Grumpy/Sunshine, Touch Her and Die Vibes, Bad Boy/Good Girl, Possessive MMC, Opposites Attract

  • Book cover for The Maddest Obsession by Danielle Lori. The cover features a woman dressed in black lace with her face partially obscured, holding a playing card with three hearts.

    The Maddest Obsession (Book 2) by Danielle Lori

    ⭐ 3.5

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I'm the Maddest Reader. This took too long and then none of Giana's worries or thoughts were resolved. They just...evaporated. And we don't know ANYTHING about Christian.” - Cardigan B

    25+ FMC, 30+ MMC, Age Gap, Brother's Best Friend, Russian MMC, Italian FMC, Mafia/Organized Crime, Enemies to Lovers, Forced Proximity, Morally Grey MMC, Obsessive MMC, Second Chance, Touch Her and Die Vibes, Slow Burn

  • Book cover for "The Darkest Temptation" by Danielle Lori. It features a man with extensive tattoos on his back and arms, holding a folded $100 bill. Title and author text are displayed in neon and white fonts.

    The Darkest Temptation (Book 3) by Danielle Lori

    ⭐ 4.25

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “What are the odds that she steps off the plane and lands her ass in The Devil's bar? It didn't have as much overt revenge as I was expecting, but I liked watching Ronan struggle with his feelings for Mila. Her poor attire seemed to work in her favor. Her dad was the definition of shithead.” - Cardigan B

    Touch her and die, Mafia/Organized Crime, Russian MMC, Age Gap, Grumpy/Sunshine, Runaway

  • Book cover titled "Vows of a Mobster" by Eva Winners. The cover depicts a woman with eyes covered by her hands, tied with a large ribbon, and a green bracelet or jewelry piece.

    Vows of a Mobster by Eva Winners

    4.0

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I was ready to call Penelope all kinds of names for this one. But I was wrong - the twists and turns were great and the story was so much better than I was expecting. The part of the book where it was the "video" of the murder was the best.” - Cardigan B

    Mafia/Organized Crime, Age Gap, Touch her and die, Sick Child, Secretary/Boss, Hidden Past, Hidden Identity, Ballerina

  • Book cover titled "Beautiful Carnage" featuring an artistic illustration of a human heart intertwined with flowers and butterflies, set against a dark textured background.

    Beautiful Carnage by Caroline Peckham & Susanne Valenti

    3.75

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “Less dark mafia, more slapstick mafia. Rocco kidnaps Sloan from her wedding to another man, they realize the feud between their families shouldn’t define their futures. A couple of unexpected twists keep it high stakes.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Kidnapping, Enemies to Lovers, Loss of Parent (Death), Forbidden Love Interest, Revenge, FMC is a Lonely Rich Girl

  • Black and white image of a man in a suit with his hands adjusting his buttons, featuring tattoos and rings, with the book title 'Bratva Lullaby' by Penny Dee at the bottom.

    Bratva Lullaby by Penny Dee

    3.75

    HOT, TO BE CONTINUED

    “She was kidnapped because her ex owed him money. And she’s been targeted three times for assassination. He promised to protect her…he didn’t.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Enemies to Lovers, Fake Engagement, Forced Proximity, Grumpy/Sunshine, Touch Her and Die Vibes, Cliffhanger Ending, Billionaire

  • Book cover for 'Chicago Ruthless: Book 1' by Sadie Kincaid, featuring a man with dark hair, a beard, and tattoos, posing with his hand near his face against a black background.

    Dante (Book 1) by Sadie Kincaid

    3.75

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “Dante was a prick who grew on me.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Enemies to Lovers, Forced Proximity, Kidnapping, Possessive MMC, Accidental/Surprise Pregnancy, Touch Her and Die Vibes

  • Cover of the book 'Joey' by Sadie Kincaid, featuring a close-up of a man and a young girl in an intimate pose. The girl has red hair and is wearing a black, sequined top. The man's face is partially visible, showing a beard and a black shirt. The text on the cover states: 'For her, he would risk everything,' 'Chicago Ruthless: Book 2,' and the author's name, Sadie Kincaid.

    Joey (Book 2) by Sadie Kincaid

    ⭐ 4.0

    HOT, HEA

    “I think it was the audio version with Joe Arden that was amazing, other than that, the book was not great. MMC is pierced.” - Penelope Black

  • Book cover titled 'Forget Me Not' by Caroline Peckham and Susanne Valenti, featuring broken glass and vibrant purple and pink flowers on a dark background.

    Forget-Me-Not Bombshell by Caroline Peckham & Susanne Valenti

    3.75

    HOT, HEA

    “Lots of action, violence, and changing dynamics. Two things that kept me from a 4-star review: 1. No way in hell a mafia boss is okay with his wife banging two other guys in front of him. 2. The punishment to his twin was not believable. It was equivalent to a toddler time out." - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Arranged Marriage, Gang Wars, Why Choose, Reverse Harem, MC is a Twin, Enemies to Lovers, Rescue, Revenge, Hidden Identity

  • Book cover for 'Merciless Saints' by Michelle Heard, featuring a man in a black suit with an open white shirt, standing in front of a dark, gothic-style building with towers and domes at night.

    Merciless Saints (Book 1) by Michelle Heard

    3.75

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I loved the idea that all of the deadliest people in the world are trained at an academy.” - Cardigan B

    Bodyguard, Academic Setting, Academic Rivals, Russian MMC, Irish FMC, Loss of Parent, Loss of Sibling, Arranged Marriage

  • Book cover titled 'Cruel Saints' by Michelle Heard. Features a young man in a tuxedo with hands clasped, head bowed, in front of a dark cityscape with historic buildings.

    Cruel Saints (Book 2) by Michelle Heard

    ⭐ 3.75

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “The setup in this story was SICK. Like...I was creeped out. Michelle Heard did a fucking great job of giving me the heebies. She finally escapes to the Academy and does the one thing she's not supposed to: befriends Lucien, the son of the head of the Mafia.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia, Academic Setting, Murder Mystery, Forbidden Love Interest, Virgin FMC, Arranged Marriage, Stalker/Stalking, Assassin, FMC & MMC Enter Into A Contract, MC has a Missing Parent

  • Book cover titled "God of Vengeance" by Michelle Heard. The cover features a man in a suit adjusting his tie, with a dark, textured background and pinkish text.

    God of Vengeance (Book 5) by Michelle Heard

    ⭐ 3.75

    HOT, HEA

    “The last in the series. It was good and I loved what an overbearing man Damiano was. And that he said "no" to her first arranged marriage, destroyed her family (as an act of love), and adored Gabriella.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Arranged Marriage, Virgin FMC, Kidnapping, MC has Interfering Family, Touch Her and Die Vibes, Morally Grey MMC, Forced Proximity, Possessive MMC, MMC Falls First

  • A black and white photo of a confident man in a suit and tie, sitting with one arm resting on his head. The image features the title "REBOUND" in large gold letters, with the subtitle "Manhattan Ruthless" and the author's name "Sadie Kincaid". A quote in the upper left corner says, "Sometimes you can have a second chance at a first try."

    Rebound by Sadie Kincaid

    3.75

    HOT, HEA

    “The ultimate second chance romance. A man puts his wife second at every turn. She finally has enough and demands separation. This story is their way back. Honestly? She shouldn’t have stayed.” - Cardigan B

    Separated/Divorcing/Divorced, Reunited after Divorce, Loss of Parent (Death), MC has Interfering Family, MC is Shunned by Family, FMC previous abused (not by MMC), First Love

  • Book cover for 'Ruthless Creatures' by J.T. Geissinger featuring a black snake coiled on a dark background with purple flowers.

    Ruthless Creatures (Book 1) by J.T. Geissinger

    ⭐ 3.75

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “The author kept setting the vibe like she was handing out burns, but really they were...pokes with a cold stick.” - Cardigan B

    “FMC kind of annoyed me. She didn't seem to ask the right questions over the year about the missing fiance or when this strange man just started stalking her. ” - Penelope Black

    MC is involved in Mafia, Neighbors, Protective MMC, Forced Proximity, Slow Burn, Touch Her and Die Vibes, Amnesia, Hidden Identity

  • Close-up of a man and woman embracing each other, with the woman touching the man's face. The man has a spider tattoo on his shoulder, and the woman is wearing bracelets. The background is dark with a Vegas-themed design, including playing cards and dice, and the text reads "Staying in Vegas" with additional details about the book.

    Staying in Vegas (Book 1) by Sam Mariano

    3.75

    HOT, TO BE CONTINUED

    “Same universe as Accidental Witness. It’s messy. She's supposed to be with Rafe, but she mouth-bangs his enforcer and falls in love in 4 days. She’s pregnant, but she acts like she's not pregnant a lot so it's easy to forget. Sin's house sounded like a shanty.” - Cardigan B

    Age Gap, Pregnancy, Kidnapping, Cliffhanger Ending, Possessive MMC, Morally Grey MMC, Bodyguard, Mafia/Organized Crime, Strong Sister Bond, Submissive FMC

  • Cover of the book "Sinning in Vegas" by Sam Mariano, featuring a shirtless man with tattoos holding a woman, set against a dark background with gambling elements.

    Sinning in Vegas (Book 2) by Sam Mariano

    ⭐ 4.0

    HOT, HEA

    “THANK GOD Sin became the MMC. Rafe sucks and it makes me not want to read book 3. He doesn't really have any redeemable qualities, especially when you read his epilogue. I loved Laurel and Sin together.” - Cardigan B

    30+ MMC, Age Gap, Older MMC, Pregnancy Kidnapping, Accidental/Surprise Pregnancy, Cliffhanger Ending, Possessive MMC, Morally Grey MMC, Tall FMC, Bodyguard, Mafia/Organized Crime, Strong Sister Bond, Submissive FMC

  • A close-up of a wedding couple holding hands, with the person's ring visible, the woman with light skin and the man with dark skin. The background is dark with floral patterns. The text on the cover reads, "Stolen Touches" by Neva Altaj, and includes phrases like "An arranged marriage mafia romance" and "Perfectly Imperfect Series."

    Stolen Touches by Neva Altaj

    ⭐ 3.75

    HOT, HEA

    “LOVED this book. Honestly, I only gave it less than 4 because I wanted more story and I would have liked more background on her POV from her time with her sister and father. It picked up too far in the future.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Mistaken Identity, Arranged Marriage, Nurse/Caretaker, MC is a Runaway, Opposites Attract

  • Book cover titled 'Tempted by the Devil: Kings of Mafia' by Michelle Heard, featuring a man in a black suit with a white shirt, clasping his hands with a large ring on his finger, against a dark floral background.

    Tempted by the Devil by Michelle Heard

    ⭐ 3.75

    HOT, HEA

    “Really good story. The plot before the marriage was heartbreaking. But the FMC was VIOLENTLY VIRGIN.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Age Gap Romance, Obsessive MMC, Possessive MMC, Forced Proximity, Morally Grey MMC, Touch Her and Die Vibes, Virgin FMC, FMC previous abused (not by MMC), Revenge, MC has a Tragic Past, MC has Bullying Siblings, "Mysterious, Brooding (MMC)"

  • Black and white cover of a book titled 'TERRIBLE BEAUTY' by Anna Zaires, featuring a close-up portrait of a young man with dark, wavy hair and intense expression, wearing a denim jacket.

    Terrible Beauty by Anna Zaires

    3.75

    MILD, TO BE CONTINUED

    “First time I have ever heard, ‘I have to drain the lady lizard’” - Penelope Black

    “No way he waited 10 years. No. Way.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Russian MMC, Age 20+ FMC, Age 30+ FMC, Arranged Marriage, Loss of Parent (Death), Abusive Parent(s), Stalker/Stalking, Virgin FMC

  • Book cover for 'Accidental Witness' by Sam Mariano, featuring a city skyline at sunset and a woman with long hair in the foreground.

    Accidental Witness (Book 1) by Sam Mariano

    3.5 & ⭐ 1.5

    MEDIUM, TO BE CONTINUED

    “BUCKLE. UP. You’re going to hate Mia. She’s too pliant and empathetic toward MAFIA MEN. She doesn’t listen. But I, Cardigan B, was hooked by this series. Try Accidental Witness and go from there.” - Cardigan B

    Mafia/Organized Crime, Witness to a crime, Young, Innocent, Naive FMC, Age Gap Kidnapping, Rape, High School, Interfering Family, Villain Becomes MMC, Captive Falls for Captor, Love Triangle, Boyfriend's Uncle

  • The book cover for 'Surviving Mateo' by Sam Mariano features a city skyline at sunset at the top, with the title in bold red text and the author's name in white at the top. The bottom shows a close-up of a woman with long, wavy hair and a man with a beard, both in a close, intimate pose.

    Surviving Mateo (Book 2) by Sam Mariano

    ⭐ 4.0

    HOT, TO BE CONTINUED

    “Not as dark, but it's fucking psychotic. Meg is strong armed into the Morelli's family and for all of her weirdness, I really liked her. I like her less now that I'm more books in, but this was an entertaining and dark read. She takes a bullet for the boss - how is this going to work out??” - Cardigan B

    Mafia/Organized Crime, Down on her Luck FMC, Age Gap Romance, FMC Gives Herself as Payment, Kidnapping, No Use of Contraception, Possessive MMC, Captive Falls for Captor, Forced Proximity, Accidental/Surprise Pregnancy

  • Book cover for 'Once Burned' by Sam Mariano, featuring a silhouette of a man with a gun at night in the background and a close-up of a blonde woman and a man in the foreground.

    Once Burned (Book 3) by Sam Mariano

    ⭐ 3.5

    HOT, HEA

    “HAHHAHAHA well this book shifts focus from Mateo to Adrian, his right hand. It's awkward and this is probably the least unsettling of the series so far, but it sets up a ton of story. Elise is a simple girl who just wants to serve. Adrian is having weird feels about it.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, "Young, Innocent, Naive FMC", Longtime Crush, Obsessive MMC, Morally Grey MMC, Revenge, MC has Interfering Family, Dark

  • Book cover for 'Family Ties' by Sam Mariano, featuring a silhouette of a couple holding hands in front of a sunset, with a close-up of a man and woman about to kiss in the lower part of the image.

    Family Ties (Book 4) by Sam Mariano

    ⭐ 3.5

    HOT, TO BE CONTINUED

    “WHOA well this explains A LOT. I loved that she kept calling Meg "the maid" because honestly, I now dislike Meg a lot. This different perspective is fascinating. I really like Francesca and Sal together.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Forbidden Love Interest, Morally Grey MMC, Power Struggle, Emotional Abuse, Touch Her and Die Vibes, Obsessive MMC, Secret Relationship, Grumpy/Sunshine, MC has Interfering Family

  • Book cover titled 'Resisting Mateo' by Sam Mariano with images of a shirtless man and two women in provocative poses.

    Resisting Mateo (Book 5) by Sam Mariano

    ⭐ 3.75

    HOT, TO BE CONTINUED

    “What the fuck is this? I kept expecting Mateo to get rid of Meg. Honestly, it's clear he wants Mia. And now he talked Meg into sharing and it's going as well as expected. It's GUTWRENCHING and impossible to see how things can get better.” - Cardigan B

    Age Gap Romance, Older MMC, MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Kidnapping

  • The cover of a book titled "Coming Home" by Sam Mariano featuring a shirtless man revealing muscular abs with a jacket, and a couple embracing on the beach at sunset.

    Coming Home (Book 6) by Sam Mariano

    ⭐ 3.75

    HOT, TO BE CONTINUED

    “Another kidnapping and another rape? There is so much of this happening. I'm as broken as all of these fucking people. Also, this is a crazy dark series...but the author won't use the word "vomit." It's always "toss her cookies" - why have multiple rapes but soften the vomit language?” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Age Gap Romance, Morally Grey MMC, Small Town Return, Redemption, Obsessive MMC, "Young, Innocent, Naive FMC"

  • Book cover for 'Last Words' by Sam Mariano, featuring a woman in a black dress with lace and a man in a dark suit, with an inset image of a shirtless man and a woman in a red dress outdoors.

    Last Words (Book 7) by Sam Mariano

    ⭐ 3.5

    HOT, HEA

    "I'm not going to be mean to the mother of my boyfriend's rape baby." <---- Sums up this series. This did NOT tie up all the loose ends and I hate that.“ - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Obsessive MMC, Morally Grey MMC, Captive Falls for Captor (Not Stockholm Syndrome), Revenge, Survival, Accidental/Surprise Pregnancy

  • Book cover for 'Entrapment' by Sam Mariano, featuring a woman with long, curly hair in black lingerie and a man in a suit, with a quote: 'Mouthy girls get punished.'

    Entrapment (Book 7) by Sam Mariano

    ⭐ 4.0

    HOT, HEA

    “WHOA. This was the best of the series, but only because it's the "deleted scenes" and fills in holes. Loved it. They added some +Adrian stories which were steamy. Loved seeing how the Carly/Madison scheme came about.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, "Young, Innocent, Naive FMC", Obsessive MMC, Age 20+ MMC, Age Gap Romance, Captive Falls for Captor (Not Stockholm Syndrome), Revenge

  • Book cover for 'The Hermit' by Michelle Heard, featuring a man in a suit with tattooed hands, standing with palms together.

    The Hermit by Michelle Heard

    3.5

    HOT, HEA

    “I’m a huge Michelle Heard fan. This isn’t her best book, but it’s alright. I couldn't get a handle on Grace - she was ferocious when it came to protecting her sister, but she deflated like a balloon when her sister wasn't in danger. Loved Santiago. I'll read his book.” - Cardigan B

    FMC previous abused (not by MMC), Rape, Arranged Marriage, Age 30+ FMC, Rescue, Sign Language, MC has a Missing Sibling, Widow, Assassin

  • Book cover of "The Kiss Thief" by L. J. Shen featuring a pink background with a lace fabric and a diamond tiara.

    The Kiss Thief by L.J. Shen

    3.5

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I really liked the first 60% of this book. The revenge plots, the hidden motivations, the spice. It was really good. But the last 40% of the book, it unraveled for me. There's cheating, pregnancy, and the MMC becomes President of the United States.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Politics, Cheating, Arranged Marriage, Virgin FMC, Rich/Wealthy MMC, Love Triangle

  • A man and woman face each other closely, with the man's hands on the woman's face and neck, both having tattoos and dark hair. The background is dark, and the title 'Marriage & Malice' is at the bottom along with the author's name, Trisha Wolfe.

    Marriage and Malice by Trisha Wolfe

    3.5

    HOT, HEA

    “She’s sold to him to pay her father’s debts. He doesn’t want a wife and plans to make her life hell. But they fall for each other. Hard. Twist at the end is actual twist.” - Cardigan B

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Ballerina, Arranged Marriage, Virgin FMC, Slow Burn, Family Rivalry, Obsessive MMC, Touch Her and Die, Dark

  • Book cover for 'The Perfect Fit' by Sadie Kincaid, featuring a butterfly combined with mechanical puzzle pieces and abstract art elements.

    The Perfect Fit by Sadie Kincaid

    3.5

    HOT, HEA

    “This shouldn't have been good. Three billionaires living in a loft together who run a train on a delivery girl with a beat up bike? It doesn't work. But for some unholy reason the characters and writing actually made it fun. I don't know what to do anymore. “ - Cardigan B

    Organized crime, billionaires, why choose, age gap, grumpy/sunshine

  • A black and white photo of a man in a suit with a city skyline in the background, and the word REAPER in large blue-green letters across the center.

    Reaper by A. Zavarelli

    ⭐ 3.5

    HOT, HEA

    “I liked this one better than Crow. Was a bit deeper with a good amount of backstory.” - Penelope Black

    MC is involved in Mafia/Organized Crime, Virgin MMC, Assassin, Accidental/Surprise Pregnancy, Stalker/Stalking, Second Chance, Age Gap Romance, Slow Burn, Obsessive MMC, Possessive MMC, Irish MMC, Grumpy/Sunshine, Forced Proximity

  • Book cover titled 'Stolen Heir' by Sophie Lark, featuring a woman with long hair, hands raised above water, with blue watercolor splash effects.

    Stolen Heir by Sophie Lark

    3.5

    MEDIUM, HEA

    “I did like this, but there wasn't enough story to give it a higher rating. It says it's a stand-alone, but I think you have to read book 1 "Brutal Prince" to care more about these characters.“ - Cardigan B

    Italian FMC, Russian MMC, Mafia/Organized Crime, Kidnapping, Ballerina, Age Gap Romance

Logo of The Storygraph featuring three books on a shelf with one slightly tilted, and the text 'The Storygraph' below.

@35CARDIGANS @BLACKCAT100

Find us on The StoryGraph

Join The StoryGraph, our romance book tracking app of choice. Scope out our TBRs, see which titles we’ve read, and watch us rate in real time. Just more proof that we’re humans.

(Yea, we also use goodreads…but so do our families. Who we’re connected to).

JOIN THE STORYGRAPH

Sizzle Scale

HOT

(Blazing & Explicit): This is the full five-alarm fire. Bedroom doors are flung wide open, and the scenes are DETAILED, EXPLICIT, and SCORCHING HOT. No fading to black here.

MEDIUM

(Simmering & Steamy): Expect passionate kisses that don't always fade to black. Could be graphic, but probably one scene that goes full throttle. Things get steamy, and the chemistry is sparking. You’ll blush, but you won’t need a fire extinguisher... yet.

MILD

(Sweet & Tender): Expect sweet sighs, maybe a stolen, chaste kiss or two, and plenty of heartwarming moments that make you go "awww." If things get more intimate, the bedroom door gently clicks shut (fade-to-black).

FLOUR

(Platonic, if anything): Rare to find around here. This is a book that has…no romance at all. We probably read this by accident.

 FAQs

  • A guide to romance novels of all heats and sizes. We’re recommending books we’ve read (we’ve read 1,000s) and telling you what to expect. We’ll help you do your research - your time and money will be happy.

  • ‘Happily Ever After’ - nearly every book you find on The Velvet Pages has an ‘HEA’. It means that the story reached a satisfying conclusion. It might say “To Be Continued” which means there’s probably an HEA in the series, but that particular title didn’t resolve the relationship.

  • This is how sexual or sexy a book is. There’s a range: Hot, Medium, Mild, and Flour.

    • Hot is ‘“holy Hell I’m sweating.”

    • Medium is steamy.

    • Mild is tender and sweet.

    • Flour means there’s nothing romantic here.

    We label each book so you know what to expect and you can choose what you’re comfortable reading.

  • We rate each book out of 5. Cardigan B and Penelope Black can rate a book the same score on occasion, but usually the rating you see is an average of their scores.

    The ratings are pretty subjective, but include things like:

    • Did the story make sense?

    • How did the characters measure up?

    • Was the writing literate?

    • Was the premise or were the plot points memorable?

    • Were the mysteries solved? Did the questions get answered? Did you leave me on ANOTHER CLIFFHANGER, ONYX STORM?

    • Did the book make us feel something?

    • Was there a cute cat?

  • We recommend starting with Historical Romance, Fantasy Romance, or Sports Romance. They’re the most popular and you’ll find recognizable tropes.

    Start with Mild to Medium heat and definitely choose an HEA.

    If you’re still stuck, email us and we can give you some recs!

    Heyyyvelvetpages@gmail.com

  • We’ll read pretty much anything. Each month, Penelope and Cardigan select a list of about 20 books to read together. There’s at least one book from each genre and some popular titles that have been recently released.

  • We sure do! It’s called ‘The Velvet Edit’. You can sign up at the top or on the ‘Contact Us’ page. We send out a themed list of recommendations each month and a ‘Quickie’ (a single title spotlight) two weeks later. We won’t spam you.

  • That’s the section of the site where we share what we’re reading this month for our book club. You can check out our other reading lists from the past few months of 2025, too.

  • Nope, not even close. The books on the site are generally the ones we enjoyed the most. Or hit on different trends we see coming up.

  • They are! If you buy from a button click on the site, we might earn a commission. You’re not paying more for the product, though. We’re all about ‘pay less for smut’ around here.

  • We use Storygraph. It has a friendly app interface and has every book we’ve read. It also shows your reading stats, which is unique.

    We have separate Goodreads accounts, but they’re connected to our friends and family and…I don’t want them to see that I read the first and second book in a series about a merman with two dicks.

  • MMC is Male Main Character. FMC is female main character.

    There are typically one of each, but there can be multiple in genres like Omegaverse or Reverse Harem.

    Or, like in the case of Court of Thorns and Roses, the MMC could be one person in one book and another person in another book.

    Don’t come at me about ‘spoilers’ - these books were published in 2015.

Email us

Looking for a book recommendation? Want to give us a recommendation you’ve read? Need to yell into the void?